An employment business has repaid five IT contractors more than £59,000 after the Fair Work Agency found their opt-outs from the Conduct Regulations were invalid, because the business could not show the client had been told. An opt-out only protects you from Conduct Regulation breaches if every condition in Regulation 32 is met, and you can prove it.
Earlier this month the Fair Work Agency (FWA) reported that an employment business had to reimburse five IT agency workers, engaged through their limited companies, more than £59,000 for 19 days’ work in May 2026. When they had not been paid, the workers complained to the FWA’s Employment Agencies Compliance team. When confronted, the business relied on two reasons to justify withholding the payment:
- The workers had left to work through another employment business; and
- each worker had signed an agreement to opt out of the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 (Conduct Regulations).
However, neither reason stood up.
Regulation 6 of the Conduct Regulations prohibits subjecting a worker to a “detriment” because the worker has taken up work elsewhere. Withholding payment for the first reason given is a “detriment” and therefore a breach of that regulation.
As the Conduct Regulations override contractual terms even if the workers contracts had authorised withholding payment, it would be unlawful to refuse to make the payment. The only circumstance in which the regulation would not apply is if the contractor and worker had validly opt out from the Conduct Regulations, which was the second reason given for the withholding.
Why there was no valid opt-out
For an opt out to be valid, not only does the employment business need to receive notice of agreement to opt out from the agency worker and company, as claimed by the agency, but the agency must notify the hirer. The FWA found there was not enough evidence that the hirer had been notified of the opt-out. With no valid opt out in place, the Conduct Regulations continued to apply, including Regulation 12 that prohibits the employment agency from withholding or threatening to withhold payment due in respect of work done, allowing the FWA to order payment for the detrimental withholding of payment.
Why is a valid opt-out so important?
The Conduct Regulations contain various restrictions on employment businesses one of which is discussed in this example. Agency workers, or contractors, working through a company are generally concerned to maintain their self-employed status. Opting out of the Conduct Regulations helps in that regard, making it easier for employment businesses to treat them as businesses rather than individuals. This in turn can help with administration and the business relationship with hirers, for example in protecting transfer fee entitlement.
What about the contract term itself?
Whilst we have not seen the contract, it is likely that it contained a provision allowing the employment business to withhold payment in the described circumstances, and was being relied upon. The mere fact that the contract contained such a clause would probably be seen by the FWA as a compliance infringement requiring removal, unless it was worded appropriately.
In ordering the payment to be made the FWA was exercising its power, which overreaches an infringing provision in the contract.
What makes an opt-out valid?
Under Regulation 32, an opt-out is only valid if:
- the work-seeker is a company, usually the worker’s own limited company
- both the company and the individual worker agree to opt out
- the employment business receives notice of the opt-out before the contractor is introduced or supplied to the client
- the employment business informs the client about the opt-out, also before the supply commences
- the work does not involve working with or attending vulnerable people, including anyone under 18
Miss any one of these and the opt-out fails. And, as this case shows, even if these steps were taken there must be clear evidence, meaning that the agency was unable to prove it was compliant. Are your processes robust enough to evidence every step?
Can you insist that contractors opt out?
No. Under Regulation 32(13) neither an agency nor an employment business can make its work-finding services conditional on a contractor opting out. It can be relatively easy to imply that services are conditional in this way. Agencies should take care not to express any view that a worker must provide an opt out to become a registered candidate of the agency, or to take up particular work if an opt-out is to be relied upon to avoid the impact of the Conduct Regulations.
After a valid opt out is in place, it remains effective until the contractor withdraws it. Notice of withdrawal is only effective once any ongoing assignment ends.
How can Lawspeed help?
Lawspeed’s contracts for limited company contractors include a straightforward built in opt-out mechanism, designed so that the right notices are given, at the right time, by the right people. Client contracts include notification to the client. Through our Proterms platform, contracts and notices can be issued and tracked, giving you a clear record if you are ever asked to evidence your position.
If you rely on opt-outs, check your process now: who signs, when they sign, and how and when the client is told. In our experience the failure to inform the client and retaining supporting evidence of that step, is the most common reason for an opt out to be invalid.
Know your position before you find yourself in an argument with the FWA. Contact us [LINK] to review your opt-out process and contracts, and if you are unfortunate enough to be investigated by the FWA over an alleged regulatory breach, contact us for support
Why Lawspeed?
26 years of advising on IR35, presenting IR35 masterclasses, and producing effective IR35 friendly contracts for use by supply agencies, hirers and contractors.
Frequently asked questions
Who can opt out of the Conduct Regulations?
Contractors working through a limited company can opt out, provided both the company and the individual agree, the correct notices are given before the contractor is introduced or supplied, and the work does not involve working with or attending vulnerable people, including anyone under 18.
What happens if an opt-out is invalid?
The Conduct Regulations apply in full, including the restrictions on withholding pay. As the latest FWA case shows, that can mean repaying withheld wages.
Can an employment business require a contractor to opt out?
No. Opting out must be the contractor’s choice, and the employment business cannot make its services conditional on it.
Why Lawspeed
26 years of advising on IR35, presenting IR35 masterclasses, and producing effective IR35 friendly contracts for use by supply agencies, hirers, and contractors.
If you have any questions on the above then please call the team on tel: 01273 236236 to discuss how we can support you.
Adrian Marlowe – CEO